Who Should Be The Top 2014 Fantasy Football Pick | FFLockerRoom.com

Who Should Be The Top 2014 Fantasy Football Pick

3-2-1… that’s the season. And with a 43-8 Seattle Seahawks victory over the Denver Broncos to become the Super Bowl Champions, the 2013 season quickly became the past. While some may find this premature, the fantasy football die hard in us already has us thinking, “Who should be the top 2014 fantasy football pick?” So who are they?


Player Team Pos Pts
Peyton Manning Broncos QB 406
Drew Brees Saints QB 348
Jamaal Charles Chiefs RB 295
Cam Newton  Panthers QB 282
Andrew Luck Colts QB 279
Andy Dalton Bengals QB 277
Philip Rivers Chargers QB 276
Matthew Stafford Lions QB 267
LeSean McCoy Eagles RB 262
Russell Wilson Seahawks QB 256
Colin Kaepernick 49ers QB 253
Tony Romo Cowboys QB 252
Matt Forte Bears RB 251
Nick Foles Eagles QB 251
Ben Roethlisberger Steelers QB 248
Tom Brady Patriots QB 241
Matt Ryan Falcons QB 239
Alex Smith Chiefs QB 238
Ryan Tannehill Dolphins QB 225
Marshawn Lynch Seahawks RB 224
Josh Gordon Browns WR 221
Knowshon Moreno Broncos RB 220
Demaryius Thomas Broncos WR 220
Calvin Johnson Lions WR 212
Jimmy Graham Saints TE 211


Not to be a pessimist, but despite being the fantasy football quarterbacks guy at FFLockerRoom I have to simply say that I have NEVER been a fan of drafting a quarterback early in fantasy football drafts. And that goes ten-fold for #1 overall, especially when the top candidates, Peyton Manning and Drew Brees, are both on the wrong side of 35. Manning in fact is just a sneeze and hiccup away from joining the 40-club. 

Early analysis shows sixteen quarterbacks placed in the top-25 for fantasy football point scorers in 2013. That alone shows that the urgency to grab a quarterback isn’t nearly as great as one would think. In fact, it should be non-existent unless you play in a annual, 6-point fantasy points quarterback league. And even then, there are so many quarterbacks and so few top running backs and wide receivers that it is very hard to side with grabbing one.

So who is left?


Player Team Pos Pts
Charles Chiefs RB 295
McCoy Eagles RB 262
Forte Bears RB 251
Lynch Seahawks RB 224
Gordon Browns WR 221
Moreno Broncos RB 220
Thomas Broncos WR 220
Johnson Lions WR 212
Graham Saints TE 211


Just looking at this list you can see who the studs and very guds (good) are. Personally I am taking off Forte, Lynch, Gordon, Moreno and Thomas. Simply they are not the best at their given position so there is no way they should be drafted #1. So the list trickles down more…


Player Team Pos Pts
Charles Chiefs RB 295
McCoy Eagles RB 262
Johnson Lions WR 212
Graham Saints TE 211


After the last cut, we are now down to four players. Four players that I truly believe deserve consideration as a #1 overall pick. Now don’t get me wrong, I am not foolish. I would never draft Graham number one overall, especially considering all of the depth of the tight end position. So we are really looking at three players here, Charles, McCoy and Johnson.

Jamaal Charles – Charles peaked at the age of 27 for the Kansas City Chiefs, playing in 15 games while grabbing 1,287 yards rushing, another 693 through the air and scoring a total of 19 touchdowns. While his overall production yardage wise was not a surprise, Charles more than doubled his previous touchdown best. With the offense set up for Charles to succeed, it is hard to believe that he will suffer much of a set-back. A return to normalcy on the touchdown front may occur though, especially his 7 receiving touchdowns. Look for a line of 1,700 all-purpose yards, 12 touchdowns and extremely satisfied owners in 2014.

LeSean McCoy – McCoy at 25-years-old proved that he could be a productive workhorse, grabbing a career high 366 total touches for over 2,100 yards and 11 touchdowns. While his visits to 6-point-land wasn’t nearly as impressive as Charles’, he did prove that his 4.2 YPC average of 2012 was more of a off-year more than anything else.

In a new offense that will be lead by Nick Foles, McCoy will be relied on heavily to carry the backfield game and should prove worthy of a top-3 choice come fantasy football draft day.

Calvin Johnson – It may be hard to believe, but Calvin is now entering his eighth season in the NFL. While his years are progressing, he is still going to be in his 20’s, 29 to be exact. He has gone for at least 1,492 yards in each of the last three seasons, with 1,964 in 2012 along with 33 total touchdowns in that span, it is hard to look past Johnson. 

In fact, with injuries to key players such as Julio Jones, it is tough to find another wide receiver worthy of the #1 overall selection in 2014 fantasy football drafts. The Matthew Stafford to CJ connection should be running at full-force, especially now that the Lions have a new regime that is offensively geared towards success. Career highs in touchdowns while a return to the 100 reception mark should be easily attainable.


In non-ppr formats I personally would recommend going with Jamaal Charles. While all three will be the main focus of their team’s offenses, both McCoy and Johnson have their own question marks. Will McCoy still remain a steady workhorse with the added elements of the Eagles offense next season, health wise and through free agency? Will Calvin actually have a second, let alone a third receiving option to help take the defensive coverage away from what will soon be a 30-year-old receiver’s body? While all three merit consideration for the first overall pick in non-ppr formats, I would go with Charles.

As for ppr formats, it is a coin flip. Last season Charles had 70 receptions, by far the best total of his career. McCoy was as steady as always pulling in his near-50 receptions, and while Johnson’s totals dipped almost 40 receptions last season, he still almost grabbed 90. In a keeper league, given all that I know and considering who would be there at the 24th pick, I would still go running back. But most likely it would be Charles as he is proving that he will be the red-zone target, both on the ground and through the air.

You can’t go wrong with any of the three, and while this list very well could change after the NFL Draft, from where everything stands right now, Charles deserves consideration as the top-overall pick in every 2014 fantasy football draft.

About Chris Ziza, Twitter Handle: @fflockerroom (1504 Articles)
Founder and Executive Director of FFLockerRoom Sports. Detroit Lions correspondent for the Fantasy Pros. Proud member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association (FSWA) and an "Approved Expert" at the Fantasy Pros. Formerly of the Most Valuable Network (MVN), the Bruno Boys and Baseball News Source.
XSLT Plugin by Leo Jiang